I remember thinking when I signed up for 360 – “this is probably Yahoo’s best-kept secret.”
I suppose I was right, in retrospect – I, like many others, came here as a result of my use of Messenger and Chat. I was introduced to 360 by the ‘gleam’ which appeared to the left of a name in my Messenger friends’-list (you might remember; that little gold asterisk which indicated an update to a user’s 360-page?)
I never saw an advertisement or any other promotion for 360. I, as with so many others, found it by accident – that over three million of us found this site useful — and found it virally, without promotion — says something; unfortunately, it’s been said too late.
We’re left with finding another site in the absence of a clear plan stated by Yahoo for our transition – but please remember; we run no risk by staying put (as long as we back up our content).
What we know is this:
1. Yahoo will be providing tools to ‘transition’ our blogs and comments. What these tools are, and to which sort of service (something outside of Yahoo, or internally) has not been stated.
2. Given this lack of clarity, the only thing we can all do is to transition our own blogs proactively (I’ve posted plenty of information in recent prior blogs on how to do this).
3. Now, we’re left with finding another blog service and getting ourselves situated before Yahoo discontinues the 360 servers sometime before the first of the year.
______________________________
I’m going to review the most-common services which have come to my attention. In the comments section, please note if there are others which we should consider.
(Note: I’d considered using screen-captures to illustrate my point – -but a better thing is to go visit the site yourself if you’re interested. I think you’ll see my point here, as things really do seem to be headed one way, regardless.)
The sites:
1. Xanga — The people who founded Xanga.Com did so with teenagers in mind; in fact, the material provided to Mashable.Com (the premier review-site for social-networking software), and Wikipedia.Org (the ‘world’s online encyclopedia’) states that the site is primarily used by teenagers.
Pro: Site has a very robust blog-entry screen, with far more tools, supported-fonts, and options than any other site.
Cons: Site is almost exclusively used by teenagers; not adults. Poor support for groups and collaborative writing; excellent support for graphics, video, vlogging, and other graphic-intensive activities – again; evocative of its support for a young audience. Xanga is also a ‘closed system’, much like 360 – which precludes listing it on promotion sites like Technorati, and obtaining cross-links from other blogging sites. Customer support is almost nonexistent; repeated attempts to contact were not returned.
2. LiveSpaces — Microsoft’s social-networking offering, Windows Live Spaces (also called MSN Live Spaces), is a social-networking and blogging site. It has an elementary front-page; nothing like what we are used to with 360 – but what killed this one for me, immediately, were the Terms of Service.
In Live Spaces’ TOS statement, you find verbiage which gives Microsoft the right to “…use, copy, distribute, transmit, publicly display, publicly perform, reproduce, edit, modify, translate and reformat your Submission, each in connection with the MSN Web Sites, and (2) sublicense these rights, to the maximum extent permitted by applicable law.” They note finally that “Microsoft will not pay you for your Submission.”
So there. In the end, you can put all the little copyright-symbols and verbiage you want in your page — but Microsoft owns your material once you post it.
You are working for Bill.
I’ll pass.
3. Multiply — Multiply.Com is a newcomer to the field, having been ‘launched’ in late 2006. The founders recently obtained a $16M round of venture-funding; this is a very positive sign for the company, as venture funds usually won’t invest in a software company unless they believe the company will either be purchased soon by another, larger company, or will make it on their own. (Note: Venture funding is usually done to bridge the gap between startup and purchase. We should remember this when making our decisions to place our blogs.)
Pro: Multiply has a very robust set of features, although the blog-entry screen is, at best, on par with 360. Still, it’s the most ‘360-like’ of the current online offerings, and is easy to modify and set-up. Customer service is excellent.
Cons: Rudimentary blog-entry screen; unknown future. Blocked as a ‘dating site’ by many corporate firewalls, making blogging-at-the-office an impossibility.
4. Orkut – Orkut is Google’s social-network offering, launched in 2004. They self-state a membership of 67M as of this date, which is considered by some to be spurious, as they stated a membership of 2M only a year before. I could find no information as to whether Orkut is a ‘closed system’ or not.
Pro: Ownership by Google; commitment to pursue this is stated in Google’s annual report. Solid software and interface.
Cons: Google has been litigated over the ‘look and feel’ of Orkut; this issue has yet to be resolved. Features (“Scrapbook”, instead of guestbook; friend categories of ‘hot’; ‘sexy’; ‘cool’) are aimed squarely at teenagers, which currently make up most of Orkut’s membership; lack of customer support, specifically regarding online harassment. Blocked by many corporate firewalls.
(I have specifically eliminated MySpace, Mash, Facebook, LiveJournal, and InCircle from the review-list, as they are all either by corporate direction aimed at a 15-24 demographic, or are too new for review.)
________________________
There you have it.
Of the list, Multiply.Com is the best of the lot – further, it appears that Multiply has the majority of the ‘expatriate 360 commu
nity’.
While Orkut, Live Spaces, and Xanga do not specifically state that they are a ‘teens only’ site, they have evolved into such by default and by the demographic which is addressed by their features. Further, the restrictive nature of Live Spaces makes its use as a blogging site for people who create valuable intellectual property in their writing a moot-point, as it’s terms-of-use grant Microsoft ownership over any material created on their servers.
All of these services are free; most offer a ‘premium’ service for a small monthly fee.
I have not reviewed ‘serious’ blogging sites (Blogger; WordPress; others) as they do not offer a friends-list or other social-networking component.
_______________________
Conclusions:
Personally, if it comes to that, I’m going to move to Multiply after careful consideration. While some of the other services provide elements I’d like to see (specifically, I’d love to see Xanga’s blog-edit screen or something like it on Multiply; I’d also like to see Multiply classed as something other than a ‘dating site’, so my friends could blog at the office) — it’s apparent we’re not going to get a full ‘360 experience’ with any of these sites.
Remember — we run no risk by staying wtih Yahoo until the end – as long as we back up our blogs and control our content.
My own criteria are (1) a stable platform for my blogging; (2) the ability to collaborate with a large group of people, (3) robust tools to do so;(4) a committed company with good customer service, and (5) an open-architecture which will allow links to other sites.
Multiply provides these — besides, as Don Henley said so eloquently in “Hotel California”: All my friends are there….